2009 Editor's Choice AwardsFish Alaska Magazine

2009 Editor's Choice Awards

...for more articles about Alaska fishing subscribe to Fish Alaska Magazine!

Another year, more gear. And while this issue has blossomed into our largest, staying on newsstands for 12 months, field testing angling equipment in Alaska isn’t always a plum assignment. Anyone who’s traveled north with a rod that is not up to the task of our Pacific salmon knows this already.

subscribe to our magazineFor Fish Alaska editors, those sorts of trials, fairly typical everywhere from Ketchikan to the Kanektok, lend a certain seriousness to our award deliberations—not only do we want to represent the best of the gear we used over the past season, equipment we can recommend to our readers with confidence, but we’re also looking for the stuff we’d use ourselves, whether packing for a weekend on the Kenai or a week’s adventure on the lonely Arolik. Our results follow, arranged in the same three categories as in years past. First are our gold-medal favorites, items at the top of the angling-equipment food chain, chosen without regard to retail price. Second is our silver-medal category, for those items that performed exceptionally under Alaska’s notoriously extreme conditions but that come with an affordable price tag. Bang for the buck is our motto here. And last but not least are our Field Favorites. Sometimes it’s a rod, other times a line, a lure, or a knife, but always our choices here are items that we found indispensable during multiple excursions over the past year.

Avet Raptor Dual Drag Reel

2010 Editor's Choice Gold Medal WinnerAvet Raptor Dual Drag Reel

$439.99,
www.avetreels.com

In usual Avet style, this model offers incredible quality through tight machining tolerances and high-quality materials. This new introduction to the line fares well in Alaska, subduing even the biggest of kings. Once these fish were adequately hooked, the Raptor made short work of Alaska’s biggest salmon, to the point it almost felt unfair when we used the reel to winch in nice Chinook from the Togiak River.

Sage 4580 Fly Reel

2010 Editor's Choice Gold Medal WinnerSage 4580 Fly Reel

$425,
www.sageflyfish.com

Based on the benchmark 2500 Series, the Sage 4500 reels are lighter and stronger, while a high-performance sealed graphite-drag unit provides the power and smoothness expected from a higher-end large-arbor reel. Paired perfectly with the TCX rods, this was the reel to use for Alaska’s salmon species and large fall rainbows.

Solitude Reels Solitude 5 reel

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerSolitude Reels Solitude 5 reel

$295 for pewter or gold, $345 for black
www.solitudereels.com

Smooth drag and fluid reeling motion are two features on this fly reel from Solitude Reels. Tested on Alaska’s kings to our satisfaction. You may be able to push the Solitude 4 on smaller kings, but the 5 is also usable for Spey fishing rods that are around 13 feet long.

Ross Reels Airius Fly Reels

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerRoss Reels Airius Fly Reels

$190 to $240,
www.rossreels.com

Designed for use in all fishing environments the Airius is a high-end, hybrid large-arbor fly reel that features a multilevel disc-drag system and large-diameter spindle support shaft that is reminiscent of a design from the old-favorite Gunnison series. This large diameter shaft provides incredible stability, and is now manufactured out of fully anodized aluminum that is strong, incredibly light and saltwater safe. After a summer in Alaska, this reel still looks (and performs) like it just came out of the box. At this price, it’s a must-have.

Lamson Velocity Fly Reel

2010 Editor's Choice Gold Medal WinnerLamson Velocity Fly Reel

$229 to $339,
www.waterworks-lamson.com

Finished in Hard Alox and totally redesigned and machined using a unique “3-plane” pocket milling technique, every aspect of performance, strength–to–weight ratio, line pickup speed and storage have been improved in this new offering over past Lamson Velocity models. With the new series, the 10-weight Velocity, perfect for Alaska’s kings, utilizes the company’s larger drag format to generate more stopping power, while there also two new spool sizes available—designed to accommodate the backing capacity needed for 8- and 9-weight saltwater reels.

Lamson Guru Fly Reel

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerLamson Guru Fly Reel

$179 to $249
www.waterworks-lamson.com

Lamson’s lowest-priced fully-machined reel, the Guru features a signature arm-style element on the frame that combines with open spokes to maximize structural strength while minimizing weight. The Guru also offers true large-arbor ratios and is available in 4- through 10-weight models. We found it held up well through a season’s work in bush Alaska, always a great benefit to a lower price-point option.

Lamson Konic Fly Reel

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerLamson Konic Fly Reel

$119 to $149
www.waterworks-lamson.com

One thing’s certain about this reel—it has a drag system made for Alaska. Equipped with the same zero-maintenance, fully-sealed conical drag that’s used on Lamson models costing $400 and up, this Konic offers super quality at a really attractive price. Whether tackling rainbows in small-stream settings or working bigger water for the state’s salmon, this reel performed faultlessly.

G. Loomis Roaring River FR1325-4 GLX Switch Rod

2010 Editor's Choice Gold Medal WinnerG. Loomis Roaring River FR1325-4 GLX Switch Rod

$740
www.gloomis.com

Switch rods are all the rage these days, offering just what they promise—the opportunity to hedge your bets and head to the water with both traditional overhead and Spey-casting styles at your fingertips. This Roaring River model from G. Loomis proved exceptionally capable whether needing to pound out 70 feet of line in a driving wind or fish mid-seams with a wall of willows at your back.

Sage TCX 690-4 Fly Rod

2010 Editor's Choice Gold Medal WinnerSage TCX 690-4 Fly Rod

$795,
www.sageflyfish.com

Marketed by Sage as “more than just another rod,” the TCX fly rods feature a radically different series of tapers created to harness Generation 5 Technology, which helped generate maximum line speed— meaning these rods were ideal for casting into the stiffest wind with the largest flies, which is basically what Alaska throws at you with regularity.

St Croix Legend Elite Spin Rod

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerSt Croix Legend Elite Spin Rod

$330,
www.stcroixrods.com

The Legend Elite series from St. Croix covers the range of rods for the trout and salmon angler in Alaska. We experimented with a rod from the spinning category of this rod family and were duly impressed with its performance, feel and styling. Its list of technical qualities is long and this series of rods merits attention from the serious spin angler.

G. Loomis 1086-4 Xperience Fly Rod

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerG. Loomis 1086-4 Xperience Fly Rod

$285,
www.gloomis.com

A new range of high-performance/high-value travel rods, the G. Loomis Xperience series fly rods utilize the same modulus graphite found in many top brands, at a very competitive price. The lighter models, with medium-fast tapers and stiffness, provide the high line speed needed for accuracy and control. As the demands of casting greater distance with larger weighted flies arise, the 8-weight and heavier models are designed with fast tapers to meet whatever challenge swims within range.

Ross Essence FW 10-weight, 9-foot, 4-piece fly rod

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerRoss Essence FW 10-weight, 9-foot, 4-piece fly rod

$229
www.rossreels.com

Ranging from 3- to 12-weight rods in the line, Ross created a medium-fast action rod that is quite a value. The titanium oxide guides proved strong when fighting Chinook on Kodiak. It was also quite a valuable tool when fighting first-run sockeye in the Kenai River in tight quarters.

Okuma Cavalla Lever Drag 2 Speed

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerOkuma Cavalla Lever Drag 2 Speed

$329.99 to $449.99
www.okumafishing.com

This reel proved a good value in the bottomfishing market segment. From impressive strike and max drag capabilities, to smooth line retrieval and aggressive gear ratios, this reel is both powerful and fast at restacking line when fighting big fish in the saltwater.

Penn Slammer 320 LD

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerPenn Slammer 320 LD

$139.99
www.pennreels.com

Built to Penn’s standard of reliability, this reel took a beating while fighting countless coho and continued to deliver smooth casts, tough stopping power, and effortless line retrieve. Its full metal body makes it heavier than other reels in this class, but also provides for the long term durability needed to effectively fish in Alaska. Combined with a full-metal side plate and body is an oversized main shaft and drag washer.

Abu Garcia Soron

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerAbu Garcia Soron

$149.95
www.abu-garcia.com

Another quality reel at an affordable price is what you’ll get if you purchase the Abu Garcia Soron. A range of features from the corrosion-resistant brass gears and aluminum body to Abu’s HPCR bearings make this a great value in the spin reel category. Five sizes are available in the line, and all offer left or right retrieve.

US Reel SuperCaster 180 Pro

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerUS Reel SuperCaster 180 Pro

$179.99
www.usreel.com

We appreciated the light weight, wide spool and distance-casting capabilities of this reel. The wide spool also imparts less memory to the line than narrower reels, and this comes in handy particularly with heavier line tests.

Quantum TE40PTIB

2010 Editor's Choice Gold Medal WinnerQuantum TE40PTIB

$239.95.
www.quantumfishing.com

This reel is among the upper echelon in performance-engineered spin reels from Quantum. Among the accomplishments of reel designers was to take major amounts of weight out while still maintaining strength. The four models in this line range from 8.4 oz. (125 yards of 4-pound-test line) to 12.6 oz. (230 yards of 10-pound-test line).

Quantum CT40PTi-B

2010 Editor's Choice Silver Medal WinnerQuantum CT40PTi-B

$149.59
www.quantumfishing.com

The Catalyst performance-tuned spinning reel allows an angler smooth operation when making long casts and packs the line quickly back on the reel after that sizzling run. Drag operation was silky for Fish Alaska gear chuckers, as was right and left hand retrieval. We fished the largest model–the 40 series–which allowed for 230 yards of 10-pound-test, provided a gear ratio of 5.2:1 and 20 pounds of max drag.

NEXT